Notable Neighborhoods of Wall Old Mill
A central section of Wall along Old Mill Road, with a mix of colonials and ranches near Route 34.
The Short Take
Old Mill At A Glance
Old Mill is one of the place names Wikipedia lists in Wall Township. A realtor guide describes it as a central section with Route 34 a few minutes away. Old Mill Road runs through the area, with Old Mill Elementary School and Old Mill Park side by side at 2119 Old Mill Road.
Sources: Wikipedia, Wall Township; New Jersey Real Estate Network (realtor guide); Wall Township, Facilities. Checked October 2026.
The Homes Colonials And Ranches
Colonials, ranches, split-levels and some newer construction, from different decades. Ranch homes are especially common.
Source: New Jersey Real Estate Network (realtor guide). Checked October 2026.
Living There Old Mill Park
Old Mill Park, next to Old Mill Elementary School, has a playground, benches and a walking path. Orchard Park, on Church Street off Route 35, has a dog park, athletic fields, playgrounds, tennis and trails.
Source: Wall Township, Facilities. Checked October 2026.
Getting Around: Route 34 And Route 35
Route 34 is a few minutes away, and Route 35 is less than a mile from Old Mill School in a straight line. NJ TRANSIT trains stop in nearby Manasquan and Spring Lake, and Wall's Parkway interchange is Exit 98.
Sources: New Jersey Real Estate Network (realtor guide); Wikipedia, Wall Township. Checked October 2026.
Home Prices
What Homes Have Sold For
For recent sales in Old Mill, ask Dennis Mark for a home value or a custom market report.
Local Favorites
Where To Eat Nearby
- Szechuan Tokyo: Chinese and Japanese. 2204 Route 35.
- Scarborough Fair: restaurant in an 1850s farmhouse. 1414 Meetinghouse Rd.
- Four Winds Restaurant: restaurant and bar. 1316 Jefferson Ave.
- Antonio's Trattoria: Italian. 2420 Route 35.
- Attilio's of Wall: pizza and Italian. 1825 Route 35.
Each checked as open in October 2026. Businesses change: check hours before you go.
Know Before You Buy
Flood Zones And Schools
Before you make an offer, look up the address on FEMA's Flood Map Service Center and ask the seller for the flood zone and any elevation certificate. Dennis Mark can pull the flood zone for any home you're considering.
Old Mill is served by Wall Township Public Schools. Old Mill Elementary School (2119 Old Mill Road) is in the area. Wall Township Public Schools assigns each address to one of its elementary schools (kindergarten to grade 5); grades 6 to 8 attend Wall Intermediate School (2801 Allaire Road) and grades 9 to 12 attend Wall High School (1630 18th Avenue).
School information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed, and boundaries change often. Verify enrollment with the school district.
Sources: Wall Township Public Schools; Wikipedia, Wall Township. Checked October 2026.
Old Mill Q&A
Common questions, each with its source. Checked October 2026.
Where is Old Mill in Wall Township?
In central Wall along Old Mill Road, with Route 34 a few minutes away. Sources: New Jersey Real Estate Network (realtor guide); Wall Township, Facilities.
Is Old Mill its own town?
No. It is one of the place names inside Wall Township. Source: Wikipedia, Wall Township.
What kind of homes are in Old Mill?
Colonials, ranches, split-levels and some newer construction. Source: New Jersey Real Estate Network (realtor guide).
Which elementary school is in Old Mill?
Old Mill Elementary School, kindergarten to grade 5, at 2119 Old Mill Road. Source: Wall Township Public Schools.
What park is in Old Mill?
Old Mill Park, next to Old Mill Elementary School, with a playground, benches and a walking path. Source: Wall Township, Facilities.
What mailing address do homes in Old Mill use?
Wall has no single ZIP code of its own for street mail, and many Wall homes carry a neighboring town's mailing name, such as Belmar, Manasquan, Spring Lake or Sea Girt. Check the municipality on the property record. Source: Wikipedia, Wall Township.
How Much Do I Think You Can Get For Your Home?
Own a home in Old Mill? Get my opinion of what it could sell for, backed by real sales data and a marketing plan.
Success Stories
I would 10/10 recommend him to anyone!!!
Dennis helped us buy our current house and has both professional work ethic and is extrememly knowledgeable. He was always there to answer any questions we had and was very patient with us in the process. I would 10/10 recommend him to anyone and he will continue to be our agent for any future needs.
We had the keys to a home within a week.
I can not recommend Dennis enough. I was referred to Dennis through a childhood friend during a very difficult time in my family’s life. The timeframe is peak covid and we had just lost our home to a house fire and had been living in a hotel for a month while I was trying to find a rental home on my own. Dennis treated us with compassion and great care during a time where we were mentally overwhelmed and numb. He took the reins and had us looking at homes the night I got in contact with him and we had the keys to a home within a week. Dennis brings a strong sense of confidence, respect and knowledge about the job and tasks required to do the job well to the table. On top of his confidence, respect and job proficiency he is also, caring, friendly and kind. I have and will continue to recommend Dennis to my family, friends and peers with confidence
He is the first and best choice you can make.
There aren’t enough words to say how much I am thankful for the amazing service and experience I had with Dennis. From going above and beyond with virtual tours to advocating on my behalf, you will not find anyone as knowledgeable and caring. I never felt like just a “client”. He took the time to get to know my needs and my family and with his help, we are now in a amazing home. He is the first and best choice you can make when buying, selling, or renting. Many Thanks.
He really brings the best of multiple worlds!
Dennis has a unique skill set that allows him to make you feel well taken care of in a trusting manner, while having the knowledge and eclectic experience in the real estate market. From the customer perspective, Dennis is a straight shooter who is honest, upfront, and tactfully comforting. Dennis’ past experience as a general contractor provided such an added level of comfort for us during all phases. He understands the physical structure he is selling which is great when you want to know on the spot if a wall can come down, or if there is a load bearing wall. He really brings the best of multiple worlds while being an authentic human who makes you feel like he truly cares where your family will be living their lives. Trust him confidently.
Absolute great human and real estate agent!
Dennis is amazing. He is firm with negotiations but is also realistic and completely transparent. If he doesn’t know the answer to a question, he immediately reaches out to his extensive network to get the answer. Absolute great human and real estate agent!
10/10 will recommend him to anyone!
Dennis is one of the most genuine individuals I’ve ever had the pleasure of knowing. He is a bold and rugged person who goes the extra mile to make sure his clients are satisfied with his work. A no nonsense type of person, he will cut things straight to the point and give you the good and bad without beating around the bush. I have seen how he handles his clients personally and cannot wait to work with him on my future purchase. 10/10 will recommend him to anyone looking to buy or rent.
The whole experience was great!
Dennis went above and beyond helping us find our home. We told him what we were looking for, and he found all the homes in our range that met our needs. Thanks to his hard work we found a home that was perfect for us, and his extensive background in construction made sure everything was up to par before helping us through the process. With his help and legwork, the whole experience was great. When there were issues on the sellers end, he went above and beyond to make sure we were getting the best deal we could. There isn’t anyone else we would trust as much as Dennis to find a home!
Professional and courteous!
Dennis did a wonderful job making the home buying experience easy. He is professional and courteous in all of his communications and would recommend to anyone who is searching for their dream home. Thank you, again!
You will be forever grateful having Dennis on your team!
I highly recommend Dennis Mark Interdonato as a realtor. My family and I lost our house in a horrible fire. We are a 4 generation family. Dennis Mark Interdonato was recommended to me by a friend on Facebook. I reached out to him. I would like to express whole-heartedly how much compassion and dedication Dennis had right from the beginning of our conversations. Dennis worked tirelessly with our insurance agent to find the perfect temporary house that required a dedicated bedroom on the main floor for my 101 year old Grandmother and also something that is pet friendly. Any questions that we had a long the way was never a bother to Dennis. When we were overwhelmed with everything, Dennis always showed us the positive side of things. When Dennis finally found a temporary rental house, which are hard to come by to begin with, he got the ball rolling right away. Dennis worked side by side with the listing agent to get us into the temporary house that we are currently in. Thank you Dennis for going above and beyond. You are amazing! You definitely deserve to be recognized for your commitment and dedication to helping us out!! If you need a realtor, you will be forever grateful having Dennis on your team!!
He’s truly dedicated to the field and it shows.
Dennis was our realtor in the home buying process. House hunting is extremely difficult in the current market, but Dennis was always there to support and guide us. He went above and beyond as a realtor and I’ll always be grateful for that. He is extremely knowledgeable about the market, wants what’s best for his clients and do everything he possibly can do to make it happen. He’s truly dedicated to the field and it shows. I would highly recommend. Thank you Dennis !
Had a great experience working with him!
Dennis was amazing. Had a great experience working with him. He walked through the buying process each step of the way and fought to get closing. He’s a great guy to have on your side you will not be disappointed. Thanks again Dennis for all your hard work
His marketing of my home was beyond anything that I expected!!
I had the pleasure of having Dennis Mark sell my home in 5 days. I knew right from the beginning I hired the perfect person to get the job done! He laid out an easy to follow plan of what we needed to do on our end and he literally took care of everything else. He was always available and prompt with texts, phone calls, and showing up exactly when he said he would. His marketing of my home was beyond anything that I expected!! I was literally the only one that had video in addition to the photos which were all amazing!! I had 2x the amount of views and saves. It was on all social media platforms. During our open houses he was texting us all day to let us know how it was going. I ended up receiving 6 amazing offers over asking. Basically Dennis will work his ass off for you. He's the whole package..trustworthy, honest, straightforward, thorough , personable, accessible, extremely knowledgeable, dedicated, professional. 20/10!! Highly recommend
We now have a lifelong friend.
I want to talk about my amazing realtor Dennis Mark Interdonato I Realtor Associate. From day one he was attentive, caring, and held our hand through the entire selling process. Told us exactly what to update, exactly what to list at, told us what buyers like and don't like, etc. We took all of his advice and our house sold the first day on the market for well over asking price. We told him what we were looking for and he helped us find exactly what we wanted. Dude did everyone's jobs for them; on both sides of the transaction: the lawyers, the lenders, all of it. He answered me pretty promptly, talked me off the ledge on more than one occasion and assured me everything would work out. When we walked into our new home after we finally closed, there were a bunch of gifts, and this is one of the gifts that was wrapped. A picture of our first home. I've been doing sales my entire life and this guy went above and beyond every step of the way. This wasn't a sale for him. We all built a relationship in the process and he helped us achieve exactly what we wanted. We now have a lifelong friend. Thank you so much for everything Dennis Mark Interdonato. If anyone needs a friend in the home selling/buying business, I would reccomend him a thousand times over.
The experience I had with Dennis Mark was like no other.
Buying or selling a home is one of the most stressful experiences for anyone. I have bought and sold a few homes and the experience I had with Dennis Mark was like no other. Full transparency, I am close friends with Dennis but he still knows how to differentiate business and friendship. Dennis made this experience absolutely stress free from the uncanny marketing of our property to alleviating all stress and always ensuring us he has everything and to just let him do what he does best. That is what he did and after so many offers in such a short timeframe we successfully sold our home and could not be happier. If you are looking for a realtor that puts the CUSTOMER first, you dont have to look further. Dennis truly cares about your experience and will bend over backwards to make it unforgettable and as stress free as possible. Thank you so much for helping us turn the page on our next chapter.
Hiring Dennis is like hiring family to buy or sell your home.
If you've decided that you are buying or selling your home, your first thought when choosing a realtor is probably "who do I know?". You want a realtor who has some kind of connection to you, in the hopes that they will, actually, look out for your best interest. I hired Dennis in the summer of 2025, to sell my house and help me into a new one. It wasn't an easy sale and my needs in a new house, were complicated at best. Dennis attacked this situation with serious energy and a critical attention to detail. My home sold pretty quickly and by October we were ready to wrap everything up. We loaded everything we owned into a truck and headed to the closing, but the best laid plans are laid to waste. There was an issue with the home I was buying, due to an error on the seller's part. What were we supposed to do now? When it became clear that we were stuck and with no place to stay, Dennis stepped in and set us up with temporary lodging near the new house. We were there for a few days while the issue was corrected. To this day whenever my son and I drive past that hotel, we wave to the "old house". I'm told that these snags are common in real estate transactions. You know what's not common? Your realtor going way out of the way to make sure you're ok at every step of the process. Hiring Dennis is like hiring family to buy or sell your home. Thank you Dennis, Ceasar Cabrales
Dennis is a marketing tornado!!
There is only one Dennis Mark. We know SO MANY REALTORS… everyone does. Dennis is in a league of his own!!! What absolutely set Dennis apart for me is his commitment, work ethic, and relentless attention to every part of the experience he provides. With him - home purchase is not a transaction. Dennis builds personal relationships and stays present long after our closing was over: love his magazine, weekly top 5 tips, helpful guides, events. Insanely love his consistent communication, his countless thoughtful ways of continuing to bring value. When it comes to marketing a listing, Dennis is a marketing tornado!!.. His digital presence, clever strategy, detailed preparation, and the number of ways he creates exposure blew me out of the water - beyond extraordinary!!!.. Everything is designed to give a client the greatest representation and exposure, producing consistent, powerful results. I appreciate how seriously Dennis takes his promises, ethics, communication, and follow-through. Love his honest and direct approach, strategic and incredibly generous knowledgeability. Couldn't speak more highly, recommend Dennis more relentlessly: anyone looking for a realtor could not find a professional who works as relentlessly, thinks so many steps ahead, and genuinely invests in the people he represents!! 🙌
Sold faster than I expected.
Dennis Mark did an outstanding job selling my home in Howell, NJ. From the very beginning, he was professional, honest, and extremely knowledgeable about the local market. He made the entire process smooth and stress-free, always keeping me updated and answering every question quickly. His marketing strategy and attention to detail really paid off — my home generated strong interest right away and sold faster than I expected. Dennis truly went above and beyond to make sure everything stayed on track from listing to closing. If you're looking for a realtor who is hardworking, straightforward, responsive, and genuinely cares about his clients, I highly recommend Dennis Mark. He's an expert at what he does and I couldn't be happier with the experience.
He doesn't sugar coat things.
Dennis and his team went above and beyond!! I live across country and they previewed multiple houses for a short term rental I needed while searching for the "forever" home to buy. Dennis always responses to my call / texts and answers my questions with extensive knowledge. He has saved me ALOT of money by guiding me and using his vast knowledge of why a house may not be right for my family's needs. He doesn't sugar coat things and explains the area, market, prices with complete honesty. He even talked me out of a home with a possible huge commission and recommended he work harder to find us the right home! If you are searching for ANY home in NJ or need advice. Dennis is your man!
His dedication and work ethic are truly unmatched.
I would like to express my wholehearted gratitude to Dennis Mark Interdonato for his exceptional dedication, professionalism, and unwavering support throughout both the sale of our previous home and the purchase of our new one. Selling a home can be stressful on its own, but navigating the complexities and challenges of our new home purchase took the experience to another level. Dennis handled every obstacle with remarkable patience, persistence, and expertise. His calm demeanor, clear communication, and strategic problem-solving were instrumental in ensuring that everything came together successfully. What truly sets Dennis apart is his genuine commitment to his clients. He went above and beyond to advocate for us, often working tirelessly behind the scenes to find solutions when situations seemed impossible. His professionalism and integrity never wavered, and he always made us feel confident that we were in the best hands possible. Thanks to Dennis's hard work and determination, we not only sold our home smoothly but were also able to secure the home of our dreams — an outcome that would not have been possible without his guidance. I wholeheartedly recommend Dennis Mark Interdonato to anyone seeking a realtor who is not only exceptionally skilled but also deeply committed to his clients' success. His dedication and work ethic are truly unmatched.
A terrific voice and incredibly helpful.
Dennis was a great support through the whole process -- from site visits to offers to negotiations to closing. He was a terrific voice and incredibly helpful during what can be a very stressful time -- weighing in on all the pros and cons, plus his deep knowledge of the housing industry was vital for me when making such a large life decision. I recommend working with Dennis
Dennis goes all out for the people he serves.
I met Dennis Mark Interdonato through our NADP professional networking group, and we hit it off right away. It was clear from our first conversation that he takes his work seriously. His presentations are always on point, and I've been equally impressed by the way he interacts with clients and his team of professionals. Dennis goes all out for the people he serves and doesn't shy away from challenging issues. He brings the kind of care and attention that helps keep closings moving smoothly and works toward the best possible outcome for his clients. I'm glad to know him and would confidently recommend connecting with him.
He's a friend to me now.
Dennis is not just a realtor to me , he is compassionate and cares about people. He is always willing to listen and help even after ! He's a friend to me now. I recommended him to anyone that wants a trustworthy good person on their side !
57 Google reviews as of October 2026. Read them all on Dennis Mark’s Google Business Profile.
Have Questions About Old Mill? Contact Us Below
Buying or selling in Old Mill? Tell me what you're looking for. See all of Wall Township.