Skip to main content

438 Prospect Avenue, Middletown, NJ 07748 · 59 photos

59-DSC05945
60-DSC05948
4 45-DSC05903
28-DSC05852
29-DSC05855
32-DSC05864
30-DSC05858
Warm cream kitchen wall refresh-3
31-DSC05861
Kitchen walls transformed to soft cream-
Bright interior with white double doors-
34-DSC05870
38-DSC05882
36-DSC05876
35-DSC05873
37-DSC05879
37-boo002
37-kk999
27-dsc0876
27-DSC05849
56-DSC05936
33-DSC05867
57-DSC05939
13-DSC05804
14-DSC05807
16-DSC05813
17-DSC05816
10-DSC05795
18-DSC05819
19-DSC05822
12-DSC05801
20-DSC05825
21-DSC05828
24-DSC05840
25-DSC05843
11-DSC05798
26-DSC05846
54-DSC05930
53-DSC05927
55-DSC05933
23-DSC05837
22-DSC05834
15-DSC05810
52-DSC05924
47-DSC05909
48-DSC05912
49-DSC05915
51-DSC05921
50-DSC05918
58-DSC05942
09-DSC00495
03-DSC00487
04-DSC00488
08-DSC00494
07-DSC00493
05-DSC00489
02-DSC00480
06-DSC00490
01-DSC00479

$749,900

  • 4 beds
  • 2.5 baths
  • 2,350 sqft

438 Prospect Avenue, Middletown, NJ 07748

Free for buyers

See new listings first thing each morning

Get an email with every new home for sale in Middletown the morning after it hits the market, and Dennis Mark's take on any of them whenever you ask. No cost, and you can stop the emails any time.

Listing courtesy of Anthony Setaro, EXP Realty

Open house: Sunday, November 22 at 12:00 PM

Overview

Beautifully maintained 4-bedroom home offering comfort, charm, and exceptional storage throughout! This move-in-ready property features spacious rooms, abundant closet space, and even a unique hidden storage room off the bedroom closet. Step outside to your own private backyard retreat, complete with a stunning in-ground pool, perfect for relaxing, entertaining, and making summer memories. Why spend weekends fighting traffic when your own resort-style oasis is right at home? Conveniently located near shopping, top-rated schools, and the Waterway Ferry for an easy commute. Pride of ownership shines throughout this home. Just unpack and start enjoying everything it has to offer!

Facts and features

Status
For sale
Home type
Single Family Residence
Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
2.5
Square feet
2,350
Lot
0.14 acres
Year built
2006
Garage
2 cars
Basement
Yes
Annual property tax
$10,367
County
Monmouth
MLS number
22636353
Days on market
2

Location

Monthly payment estimate

Estimate only

$4,656 /month, estimated

Principal and interest
$3,792
Property tax
$864
Home insurance
Not included
HOA dues
Not included

An estimate for planning only, not a loan offer or a rate quote. The 6.5% rate is an example to change, not today's rate. Your lender sets your actual rate, payment and costs, which include items not shown here such as mortgage insurance.

Last updated: 11/22/2026 at 2:40 AM ET

Listing courtesy of Anthony Setaro, EXP Realty

Listing information provided by MOREMLS (Monmouth Ocean Regional REALTORS®).

Listings have been excluded from display: this search shows New Jersey homes only.

Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and may be inaccurate. Listings may no longer be available. Provided for consumers' personal, non-commercial use only; it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify properties consumers may be interested in buying. Copying, scraping or reuse of this data is prohibited.

By using this search you agree to our Terms of Use. Privacy

Back to the home searchOur ListingsContact Dennis Mark

438 Prospect Avenue, Middletown, NJ 07748 | $749,900 | Dennis Mark Interdonato