Does the Seller Get to Pick Your Title Insurance Company in NJ?
Published | Posted by Dennis Mark Interdonato
- Insider Insights
- Home Buying
- Closing
- New Jersey
No. Under federal law, a seller can't require you to buy title insurance from a particular company as a condition of selling you the house. When you're buying with a federally related mortgage loan, the choice of title company is yours to shop.
I'm Dennis Mark Interdonato, a REALTOR® and Master CDRE® with The Dennis Mark Group at Keller Williams Realty Ocean Living. A buyer may see a title company's name early in the paperwork and assume they're stuck with it. Here's what the law says and how to shop for title insurance in New Jersey.
First, where I stand. I sell homes. I'm not an attorney or an insurance professional, and I'm not licensed to give legal or insurance advice. This is my own reading of federal law, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and the New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance on November 22, 2026. I could have something wrong, so confirm anything about your purchase with your real estate attorney, your lender or a licensed title professional.
What does the law say about the seller and the title company?
The rule is Section 9 of the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act, known as RESPA. It says no seller of property that will be bought with the help of a federally related mortgage loan may require, directly or indirectly, as a condition of selling, that the buyer purchase title insurance from any particular title company.
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has a page for this exact situation: a seller says you have to use a certain title company or they won't sell. The agency's answer is a flat no.
The law has teeth, too. A seller who breaks it is liable to the buyer for three times all charges made for that title insurance. The CFPB's Regulation X repeats the rule.
Because the rule is federal, it reads the same in Monmouth County, Ocean County and everywhere else in New Jersey.
Where does the misconception come from?
Part of it is how a sale comes together. A seller, a seller's attorney or a builder may have a title company they like, and its name can come up early. In my reading, a seller can suggest a company. Under Section 9, a seller can't make one a condition of the sale.
The other part is that lenders usually do require a title policy. Buyers hear that title insurance is required and assume someone else picks the company. Those are two different questions.
What does title insurance actually cover?
There are two policies, and they protect different people.
- Lender's title insurance. The CFPB says it's usually required to get a mortgage loan. It protects the lender against problems with the title, such as someone with a legal claim against the home. It only covers claims that affect the lender's loan, and it doesn't protect your equity.
- Owner's title insurance. This policy protects you. The CFPB says it can help if someone later sues and says they have a claim against the home from before you bought it. Its examples include a previous owner's unpaid taxes and contractors who say they weren't paid.
New Jersey's Department of Banking and Insurance calls title insurance a one-time fee paid at closing. Its homebuyer guide says that, except for privately financed purchases, your lender will require it in essentially all cases. For a privately financed purchase, the guide says you should consider buying title insurance anyway, to protect you from claims against prior owners.
The guide also says most purchase agreements are conditioned on a title search. If someone else has a claim against the property, the seller's title isn't clear, and your real estate attorney can evaluate it and advise you.
How do you shop for title insurance in New Jersey?
The CFPB says you can usually shop for your title insurance provider separately from your mortgage, and that shopping could save you money. Here's how I'd go about it.
- Read your Loan Estimate. The CFPB explains that the "Services You Can Shop For" section lists services the lender requires but lets you shop for separately. The lender should give you a list of approved providers along with the Loan Estimate. You can pick one from it, or check with your lender about a provider that isn't listed.
- Ask about buying both policies from one provider. If you choose owner's title insurance, the CFPB says the total cost is usually lower when the same provider writes both the lender's policy and the owner's policy.
- Compare the bottom line. The CFPB notes that the itemized fees a title company gives you under state law can look different from the same fees on your Loan Estimate or Closing Disclosure. Add up all the title-related costs and compare the totals.
- Bring your attorney in early. Ask which title company they'd suggest, and why.
One more New Jersey piece: the Department of Banking and Insurance regulates title insurance sold in the state, including its rates, rules and policy forms.
What should you do if a seller insists on a title company?
Stay calm and put it in front of your attorney. Ask whether the seller is stating a preference or making it a condition of the sale. If it's a condition and you're using a federally related mortgage loan, Section 9 is the part of the law your attorney will want to look at.
You're also free to choose the company the seller suggested if its price and service work for you. The law protects your right to choose.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is owner's title insurance required in New Jersey?
The CFPB describes the lender's policy as the one usually required to get a mortgage, and the owner's policy as one you may want to buy to protect your own investment.
Does the RESPA rule apply if I'm paying cash?
By its own words, Section 9 covers property bought with the help of a federally related mortgage loan. If you're paying cash, ask your attorney what applies.
Can my lender choose my title company?
Some closing services are chosen by the lender. The CFPB says those appear under "Services You Cannot Shop For" on the Loan Estimate, and the ones you can shop for appear under "Services You Can Shop For." Check which section your title services sit in.
One more time, so it's clear: this is my research, not legal or insurance advice. I'm a REALTOR®, not an attorney or a title professional, and your attorney has the final word on your contract. If you're buying and want a second set of eyes on your Loan Estimate or your closing timeline, send me a note with the form below. Next, read what it costs to buy a home in New Jersey, or browse more Insider Insights.
This is general information, not legal, tax or lending advice. Sources: 12 U.S.C. 2608 (RESPA Section 9), the CFPB's Regulation X and Ask CFPB pages, and the New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance, read November 22, 2026.
About the author
Dennis Mark Interdonato is a REALTOR® and Master CDRE® who leads The Dennis Mark Group at Keller Williams Realty Ocean Living in Point Pleasant, NJ, helping buyers and sellers throughout New Jersey make their next move, with Monmouth and Ocean County as home base. Read more about Dennis Mark.










