Renting Out the Marital Home Instead of Selling in a NJ Divorce
Published | Posted by Dennis Mark Interdonato
- Divorce
- Rental Property
- Capital Gains Tax
- New Jersey
Yes, two divorcing owners can keep the marital home and rent it out instead of selling, if your agreement allows it. Renting changes three things: the tax break on a later sale, how the two of you split the rent and the bills, and the New Jersey landlord rules you take on when a tenant moves in.
I'm Dennis Mark Interdonato, a REALTOR® and Master CDRE® with The Dennis Mark Group at Keller Williams Realty Ocean Living. In a divorce, renting the house out is a third option, next to selling it and one spouse keeping it, and it needs the same clear numbers.
First, where this comes from. It's my own research from IRS Publications 523 and 527, New Jersey's landlord registration law and the NJ Department of Community Affairs' Truth in Renting guide, read on November 15, 2026. I'm not a tax professional or an attorney, and I'm not licensed to give tax, accounting or legal advice. I could have a detail wrong, or a rule could change, so take these questions to your tax professional and your attorney.
What changes when you rent the house instead of selling it?
When you sell, the house turns into money, and the money gets divided. When you rent, the house stays a shared asset, and the two of you stay in business together as landlords. Whether that's allowed, for how long, and what triggers a sale later is for your attorneys or mediator to put in writing, along with who collects the rent and who pays the bills.
What does renting do to the tax break when you sell later?
Publication 523 lets you exclude up to $250,000 of gain on a main home, or $500,000 on a joint return, if you owned it and lived in it for at least 24 months of the 5 years before the sale. Renting doesn't erase that, but the clock runs.
- The window moves. Every month the house is rented is a month neither of you lives there, so a long rental can push you outside the 24-month test.
- Time after you move out. Publication 523 calls any period after 2008 when neither you nor your spouse or former spouse used the home as a main home "nonqualified use." Time inside the 5-year window after the last date either of you lived there doesn't count against you.
- Depreciation. In the IRS's example of a home rented after the owner moved out, the owner can't exclude the part of the gain equal to the depreciation claimed, or that could have been claimed, for renting it.
Publication 523's rule for separated owners counts a spouse living in the house under a divorce or separation instrument, not a tenant, so have your tax professional check your dates.
How do two owners split the rent and the bills?
Publication 527 says that if you own a part interest in rental property, you report your part of the rental income, and you deduct the expenses you paid according to your percentage of ownership.
In its example, an owner with a one-half interest pays a $968 repair, deducts $484, and is entitled to reimbursement for the other half from the co-owner. If one of you pays a bill the other owes half of, your agreement should say how that gets settled.
Publication 527 also says a home you lived in and then rent out is depreciated from the lesser of its adjusted basis or its fair market value on the day it becomes a rental. That's one more reason to know what the house is worth.
What does New Jersey require before a tenant moves in?
- Registration. Under N.J.S.A. 46:8-28, a one-unit rental is registered with the municipal clerk. The state's guide says the statement names the owner or owners, every holder of a recorded mortgage, an emergency contact with a phone number, and, if the owner isn't in that county, a person in the county authorized to accept legal papers. Changes are filed within 20 days, and a landlord who isn't properly registered can't evict a tenant.
- Smoke and carbon monoxide alarms. The owner of a one- or two-unit house needs a certificate of alarm compliance from the local fire official, and the guide says that's enforced on any change in occupancy.
- Lead paint, for homes built before 1978. The federal rule calls for a lead disclosure form in the lease and an EPA lead pamphlet given to the tenant before the lease is signed. New Jersey also requires one- and two-unit rental homes built before 1978 to have a lead inspection and risk assessment with any hazard control work, or periodic treatment, unless an exception applies, such as a certified lead-free interior.
The Truth in Renting statement itself goes to tenants in buildings with more than two units, so a one-unit house usually isn't covered by that part.
Who holds the tenant's deposit when there are two owners?
The guide says a deposit can't be more than one and one-half times one month's rent. It stays the tenant's money, held in trust, and a landlord with ten or fewer units keeps it in an interest-bearing account at an insured New Jersey bank or savings and loan. The tenant gets written notice of where it's held within 30 days.
After the tenant moves out, the deposit comes back within 30 days, with interest and an itemized list of any deductions. Decide in writing whose name is on that account and who sends the notices.
Where does a sale fit in later?
If the plan ends with a sale someday, the tax rules above put a clock on that day. A neutral valuation helps whether the home is sold or one of you keeps it. I prepare a market evaluation from recent comparable sales, and both of you, along with your attorneys or mediator, see the same report.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do both of us have to be named as landlords?
The registration asks for the owner or owners, so if you both still own the house, plan on both names. Your attorney can tell you how the lease should be signed.
Does renting it out mean we lose the home sale exclusion?
Not automatically. Publication 523 still looks for 24 months of use in the 5 years before the sale, and rental time after the last date either of you lived there, inside that window, isn't counted against you.
One last time: this is my research, not tax, accounting or legal advice. I'm a REALTOR®, not a CPA or an attorney, and something here may be wrong or out of date by the time you read it, so your tax professional and your attorney have the final word. If the first question is what the house would bring today, start with a neutral home value both of you can see.
This is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or lending advice. Sources: IRS Publications 523 and 527 (2025 editions, last updated April 30, 2026), N.J.S.A. 46:8-28 as posted by the NJ Department of Community Affairs, and the Department's Truth in Renting guide as posted when I read it on November 15, 2026.
About the author
Dennis Mark Interdonato is a REALTOR® and Master CDRE® who leads The Dennis Mark Group at Keller Williams Realty Ocean Living in Point Pleasant, NJ, helping buyers and sellers throughout New Jersey make their next move, with Monmouth and Ocean County as home base. Read more about Dennis Mark.










